Kirkus Review
A collection of 17 new and three reprinted stories plus an essay, weaving among the prolific Modesitt's impressive 18-book (and counting) fantasy Saga of Recluse (Heritage of Cyador, 2014, etc.).Briefly, the series describes the fate of a spaceship from an advanced starfaring civilization suddenly hurled into another universe where science and engineering work only intermittently; instead, the structure of spacetime gives rise to highly specific types of magic, to the bewilderment of the humans who now must make new lives there. Helpfully, the stories present in the internal chronological order in which they occur in the world of Recluce. Since neither a timeline nor maps are included, however, familiarity with both is assumed. First, and most significant (although fiction purists may disagree), the essay describes how Modesitt developed the ideas and logic behind the opposing (black) order and (white) chaos magics that characterize the series, how the magics gave rise to the planet's distinctive social systems, how the social systems conflict and combine, and why the series' most powerful characters arise almost organically out of this complex and satisfying backdrop. Laconic introductions to each story inform us that Modesitt wrote them to fill gaps in the saga, in response to readers' questions or pleas, to view landmark events from unfamiliar perspectives, or sometimes "just because." A sampler: in "Heritage," clairvoyant Empress Mairena must persuade skeptical soldiers and citizens to flee the coming destruction of Cyador; "Black Ordermage" details how the mage Cassius came to Recluce (and no, he wasn't born there); in "The Forest Girl" we encounter the future emperor Alyiakal and his dealings with the Accursed Forest; and in "Worth," Wrynn, a fearsome and multitalented warrior, seeks the serenity that eludes her. Don't expect great significance everywheresome of the pieces are no more than vignettesbut Modesitt is excellent company, and the more familiar you are with the series, the richer these stories will seem. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
The stories in this collection, set in the world of Recluce, offer glimpses of characters and times that have been mentioned in the novels of Recluce and allow the author to provide alternative viewpoints that give depth to events that otherwise would remain untold. This collection is written by Modesitt no fan fiction here almost as though the characters or events were calling to him to write their stories as well. At the start of each tale, the author provides a very brief paragraph of thought about why and what the story touches upon. Freed from the length of a novel, the beauty of the world that Modesitt has created becomes even more apparent. It almost seems as if these could have been addendums to the original novels. Not for those who are not familiar with Recluce, but a must-read for those who are already deeply enchanted.--Gerber, Rebecca Copyright 2017 Booklist
Library Journal Review
In his 18-volume "Saga of Recluce" novels, Modesitt chronicled the 1,000-year history of the Island of Recluce. This new collection features 21 short stories (four are reprints) that span the history of the series. It opens with an essay on how the author developed the complex magic system used on Recluce; the following pieces offer a time line of both familiar and new highlights. A young mage faces a choice between saving the lives of his people or their wealth, but will his dilemma be enough to warrant "Madness?" When readers want to know what happens to a favorite character after they wander off the page, Modesitt shows that the answer is not always what it is "Worth." VERDICT Fans of Modesitt's best-selling saga will find this collection enhances their enjoyment of that series. New stories offered here serve as a foil to the main series, with the same rich detail and exciting lands to explore.-KC © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
