School Library Journal Review
Gr 6-8-The story begins with the disappearance of Oscar, whose bicycle was found at the edge of a pier. He is presumed drowned. His best friend, Meg, knows he can't be dead, but only Oscar's younger brother shares that belief. Meg begins to investigate, trying to uncover the boy's whereabouts. The work is told in two voices, Meg's and Oscar's, and teens will slowly piece together the events that led up to the disappearance. In flashbacks, readers learn about the relationship of these close friends and next-door neighbors. Oscar is gentle and perceptive, a boy whose ability to create happiness and contentment with his special apple tarts make him a well-liked person. When Meg's parents relocate the family to New Zealand for a year, she is devastated and doesn't want to leave. Meanwhile, things begin to fall apart for Oscar when a new girl, Paloma, moves in next door. When she is gently rejected by Oscar, she manipulates his feelings, and the kids at school make Oscar pay for his rejection. On one hand, this is a very sweet story about first love. Readers will delight in watching Meg and Oscar transition from friendship to love while they become enraged at Paloma's bullying behavior. In addition to the romance, there is also plenty of intrigue and mystery to engage readers not typically drawn to love stories. VERDICT Sweet romance encased in a compelling mystery.-Patricia Feriano, Montgomery County Public Schools, MD © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Booklist Review
*Starred Review* Irish 14-year-olds Oscar and Meg are not just next-door neighbors, they are best friends who share all their dreams and struggles and draw strength from each other. When Meg's father needs to leave Ireland for a six-month research sabbatical in New Zealand, it's Oscar who encourages Meg to embrace the opportunity. But her absence leaves Oscar in a dark place where he is bullied and pushed to the breaking point. Oscar's decision to bike off the local pier into icy waters brings Meg home under circumstances she never could have foreseen. This beautifully constructed story begins with the Day of Prayer for Oscar, who is missing and presumed dead. Told in alternating chapters by Oscar and Meg, their friendship, and subsequently deeper feelings, are slowly revealed to the reader, climaxing in a wonderful revelation of truth. Fully developed secondary characters such as Oscar's disabled younger brother and Paloma, who tries to take Meg's place add richness and depth to this lyrically written tale, which explores themes of manipulation, self-discovery, hope, and love. Middle-school readers taken with Ali Benjamin's The Thing about Jellyfish (2015) will be drawn to Oscar and Meg's story. This touching novel is one to savor.--Moore, Melissa Copyright 2016 Booklist
