School Library Journal Review
Gr 9 Up-Maddie O'Neill Levine and her grandmother, Astrid North O'Neill, are best friends. That is, until her Gram announces to her family that she has terminal cancer and has arranged for one last trip, a secret "death with dignity" cruise on the Wishwell. Maddie had planned to hang with her friends by the lake all summer, but instead her family drops everything for one last trip with their dying Gram. They embark on a voyage of discovery that serves as a catalyst to discuss death, dying, and grief, where the cousins, especially Maddie, are forced to grow up. The trip starts with Maddie's immediate O'Neill family, but by the end "the Wishwellian" ship becomes a family brought together by death. The characters on the ship are relatable, endearing, and lovable. Filled with equal amounts of laugh- and tear-inducing moments, this debut novel will be impossible to put down. Fans of Jenny Downham's Before I Die or Jonathan Tropper's This Is Where I Leave You will enjoy this unique story about dying on one's own terms. Mentions of drinking, drugs, and sex make this title appropriate for older readers. VERDICT With its fresh, original plot and thought-provoking themes, this title will have a high teen appeal.-Morgan O'Reilly, Riverdale Country School, NY © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publisher's Weekly Review
Maddie is eager to spend the summer before college completing her list of missed opportunities with her best friends until her wealthy grandmother delivers a bombshell. Dying of pancreatic cancer, Gram bids Maddie and family to take an eight-week cruise on The Wishwell, a "death-with-dignity" ship catering to its passengers' last desires. Together with her parents, brother, sex-crazed cousin Janie, assorted aunts and uncles, and Gram's boyfriend, Bob Johns, Maddie travels around the world collecting "snow globe moments" to cherish forever. Along the way, she falls in love with Enzo, a British college student headed to Egypt. Joyful shipboard scenes eventually give way to sadness as members choose their final moments. Afraid of death, Maddie must come to terms with the decision her grandmother and the other Wishwellians make. First-time author Firestone's memorable characters offer powerful images of bodies betraying lively minds and spirits. While the often crass dialogue and narration can feel at odds with the overall emotional tone ("I can't escape the horrifying visual of Gram's bony body getting slammed by old Bob Johns"), the novel culminates in an embracing celebration of life. Ages 14-up. Agent: Sara Crowe, Harvey Klinger. (June) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Booklist Review
Maddie thinks she's going to spend the summer after high-school graduation hanging out at the lake with her best friends, but her wealthy, eccentric grandma has a different plan; she's taking the entire family on a cruise. The catch is that Gram has pancreatic cancer, the Wishwell is a death-with-dignity cruise, and everyone aboard will either be a terminally ill patient or a patient's friends and family. Once on board the Wishwell, Maddie connects with Enzo, son of the Wishwell program's founder, and her family a cast of crackling personalities becomes enmeshed in the community on the ship, with all the joy and sadness that comes with people experiencing their final days. Firestone stuffs her novel with warm and wonderful characters and intricate side plots, and though some moments strain credulity, the combination of snappy dialogue; no-holds-barred teen antics (with lots of sex, drugs, and drinking); and an offbeat family at its heart gives it plenty of appeal. A bright, promising debut that will resonate with lots of teens.--Scanlon, Donna Copyright 2016 Booklist