Reviews provided by Syndetics
Publishers Weekly Review
Less than a year ago, 12-year-old Trent Zimmerman accidentally contributed to the death of his teammate Jared during a hockey game, after nailing him with a puck (Jared had a "bad heart"). Already prone to overthinking, Trent is overwhelmed by disturbing thoughts, which he draws in a closely guarded book, and very angry. He backs away from his best friend, acts out at school, and clashes with his family. With help from a persistent classmate, who is known as much for the large scar on her face as for her weird outfits, and a similarly dedicated teacher, Trent is gradually able to let go of his intense guilt and regain his confidence. Trent's barely constrained rage is visceral, and the moments when he lashes out, verbally and physically, are as frightening as they are realistic. In an ambitious and gracefully executed story, Graff (Absolutely Almost) covers a lot of emotional ground, empathically tracing Trent's efforts to deal with a horrible, inexplicable accident and to heal the relationships that have become collateral damage along the way. Ages 10-up. Agent: Stephen Barbara, InkWell Management. (May) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
School Library Journal Review
Gr 4-6-Ever since a freak hockey accident killed his friend Jared, Trent has felt guilty and angry and thinks everyone hates him. After all, it was his stray shot that hit Jared. He lashes out at teachers, ignores his friends, and feels misunderstood by family. When Fallon, a girl with a secret, befriends him and won't take no for an answer, he reluctantly opens up. Narrator Ramon de Ocampo's unique intonations and voice bring to life Trent's world with ease. The author expertly handles the topic, and the plot is engaging, but the characters' motives are stiff and unbelievable at times. Readers will laugh and cry as they relate to Trent's flawed character and his struggles to forgive himself. VERDICT A good choice for those who enjoy realistic fiction, need help dealing with grief, or like audiobooks about the healing power of friendship.-Jessica Moody, Olympus Jr. High, Holladay, UT © Copyright 2015. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Booklist Review
*Starred Review* Middle school is tough, but try getting through sixth grade after accidentally killing someone with a hockey puck. Such is Trent Zimmerman's misfortune. Wracked with guilt and anger, he is never without his Book of Thoughts, the sketchbook where he draws the awful images he can't get out of his brain. Sure that everyone hates him, Trent acts out at school, shuts out friends, and is overcome by sweaty panic at the thought of playing sports again. Life is difficult at home, too, where his parents' divorce has resulted in a contentious relationship with his father. Relief comes in the eccentric form of Fallon Little, a girl with a mysterious scar and an indomitable spirit. But Fallon has her secrets as well. The emotions and motivations coursing through this novel are wonderfully complex. Graff creates layered, vulnerable characters who are worth getting to know and rooting for. Narrated by the moody, sarcastic Trent, the story never buckles beneath his troubles, and it finds wings once he can see beyond them. Pranks, The Sandlot reenactments, sports talk, and doughnuts are in plentiful supply, adding dashes of levity at the right moments. The book's real magic is found in simple acts like watering plants and learning when to listen and when to just tip your head back and scream at the sky.--Smith, Julia Copyright 2015 Booklist
Horn Book Review
I didnt do it on purpose, obviously, says twelve-year-old Trent Zimmerman. Kill Jared Richards, I meanBut accident or not, Jared Richards died, and I was the reason, so what was the difference? Either way, I killed him. Trent mistakenly shot a hockey puck into Jareds chest, and Jared, who had a heart defect, died. Now Trent is lost in self-absorption, convinced everyone hates him, and filled with a rage thats always about to boil over. His parents are divorced, and he avoids spending time with his father; he calls his teacher a wrinkled old crone; he beats up a kid; and hes getting lousy grades. Like the outfielder who loses a fly ball in the sun (per the books title), Trent has lost sight of what matters most in his life. After befriending Fallon Little, the girl with the scar, Trent gradually sees how his actions have affected everyone around him. Readers may find the storys pace slow and Fallons tale frustratingly unfinished, but Trents powerful first-person narrative may resonate with young people who often feel lost in situations beyond their control. Family, friends, and even that old crone Ms. Emerson have been there all along; Trent just had to learn to see them. dean schneider (c) Copyright 2015. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Book Review
When internal anger turns into outward rage, one middle school misfit must find a solution or risk ruining everything that matters.Trent Zimmerman can't help it. It's not his fault that his dad hates him, and his teacher, the old crone, hates him, and his old friends hate him. Only, well, he feels so guilty. Maybe it is his fault. Ever since the accident back in February, when Trent accidentally hit a hockey puck into Jared Richards with catastrophic results, his life has been turned upside down. When middle school starts in the fall, Trent believes it's a chance to start fresh, only it doesn't take long for him to realize that no one has forgotten what happened to Jaredespecially Trent. Now his anger is getting bigger and bigger, pushing against his insides and making Trent lash out. If that isn't crazy enough, he finds himself in a bizarro friendship with terribly scarred Fallon Little, who just might be able to teach Trent how to value himself. Graff writes with stunning insight into boyhood and humanity, allowing Trent to speak for himself in a pained, honest narration. Investing Trent with all the tragic frailty of Holden Caulfield, Graff tackles issues of loss, isolation, and rage without apology.Graff consistently demonstrates why character-driven novels can live from generation to generation, and here she offers a story that can survive for many school years to come. (Fiction. 9-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.